What is a used Winchester Model 1876 worth today?

Based on current market trends, a Winchester Model 1876 in very good to excellent condition typically sells in the $1,000 to $5,000 range. Pricing can be lower for heavy wear or missing parts and higher for like-new condition, upgrades, or desirable configurations.

What factors affect the value of my Model 1876?

Condition is the biggest driver, then configuration and included accessories. Things like overall wear, bore condition, finish, function, optics, extra magazines, chokes, boxes, paperwork, and original parts can all move the value up or down.

Will you buy my Model 1876 if it’s worn, modified, or missing parts?

Often yes. Normal wear, many common upgrades, and minor issues are usually fine. Just note anything important in the description and include clear photos so we can price it accurately.

How do I ship my firearm safely and legally?

After you accept an offer, we send a prepaid shipping label and step-by-step instructions. You’re responsible for packaging the firearm securely, then you drop it off with the carrier. All transfers are handled through the proper FFL process.

How quickly will I get paid?

Payment is sent by check or ACH direct deposit. After we receive and verify the firearm matches the submission, payment is issued quickly. You’ll choose your preferred method during acceptance.

Make/Model Valuation Guides Winchester Model 1876

Published: October 29, 2025 | Updated: January 31, 2026

How Much is My Winchester Model 1876 Worth?

Curious about how much your Winchester Model 1876 is worth? Whether you’re looking to sell or simply understand its worth, we’ll help you assess the market value of this iconic and reliable rifle.

Based on current market trends, a Winchester Model 1876 in very good to excellent condition typically retails for between $1,000 and $5,000. Note that values are highly contengent on condition and originality of parts.

Get a free offer Our reviews ↓ Our process ↓

Winchester Quality

Valuing the Winchester Model 1876

The Winchester Model 1876 is a large-frame lever-action built to handle more powerful cartridges. It saw use with hunters and on the frontier, with limited production compared to later models.

Variants include short rifles and carbines, plus deluxe options with upgraded wood and sights. Original configuration and condition are the key value drivers.

At WeBuyGuns.com, we understand the market value of these firearms and are committed to providing you with a fair and competitive offer. Submit your Winchester Model 1876 today for a free valuation and let us make an offer that reflects the quality and legacy of your firearm.

Common Variants of the Winchester Model 1876

The Winchester Model 1876 is available in a variety of models and configurations, each catering to different shooting needs and preferences. Below are some of the most popular variants, each offering unique features:

Carbine

Handy saddle-ring format; typically lighter and more compact for field use.

Rifle / Short Rifle

Longer barrels and varied sights; deluxe wood and finish options command premiums.

Don’t see your specific model listed? No problem!

We value firearms of all types, whether they’re common or unique.

Start your free, no-obligation offer!

Factors That Influence Winchester Model 1876 Values

When determining the value of your Winchester Model 1876, several factors come into play. Here’s what we consider:

Condition: Firearms in excellent condition — clean bore, minimal wear, and no significant damage — will command higher prices.
Accessories: Adding accessories, optics, additional magazines and having original packaging can increase value.
Rarity: Limited edition and vintage Winchester models in pristine condition often have added value.
Market Demand: Popular models perform well on the market due to their practicality and widespread use.
Original Box & Documentation: Presence of the original Winchester box or case can increase offer value, lack of the original box will typically decrease the offer value.
Aftermarket Modifications: Aftermarket modifications and finishing can affect offer values but rarely add significant value in the secondary market.

Recent customer reviews

Ben Falchi

★★★★★ Jan 31, 2026

Very easy and fast! I will be buying and selling from we buy guns again!

larry

★★★★★ Jan 30, 2026

These guys are the best they gave me the money I wanted and in a timely manner I'm very satisfied with their service they did exactly what they said they would do and I got nothing but respect for these guys thank you

Houston Taylor

★★★★★ Jan 30, 2026

Great company to deal with, decent offer and the process was fast. Will do business with again.

Sam Barbagallo

★★★★★ Jan 30, 2026

effortless

Tommy

★★★★★ Jan 30, 2026

Simple and fast! I’ll admit, like most people, I was super skeptical about this process. Sending someone your firearm with zero guarantee you’ll get your money was sketchy. However, fear not! They provided me a shipping label, I mailed it off, and was paid 2 days after they received it. I also got $100 over what I was offered at a local pawn shop. Awesome option for anyone looking to sell their firearms.

Jacob Krygoski

★★★★★ Jan 30, 2026

Smooth and timely transaction

Jason Balazs

★★★★★ Jan 30, 2026

Was worried about sending my pistol, first time I ever did that. They made it seem less and easy. Great business

Hilda Alford

★★★★★ Jan 29, 2026

Easy process. Fair offer.

Joe G

★★★★★ Jan 29, 2026

I highly recommend We Buy Guns. I was skeptical at first but I read multiple reviews and researched their website. Oh my gosh, the process is so easy. They offered me a very fair price, and they cover shipping cost. This is the best way to sell a firearm. The process was fast and I was kept abreast via email of every step being taken. Their entire process is excellent. Your only real task if you accept their offer, is to properly pack the firearm with paperwork in a proper sized box, which I purchased at UPS store. From start to finish a really simple and great process. I give them 5 stars all the way. Finally, I live in the state of PA in case other Pennsylvanians are wondering about ease of selling a firearm

Ben Samuel

★★★★★ Jan 28, 2026

Honest people to deal with. Did what they said they would do. Selling to them was eazy and quick you can't go wrong.

Start your free offer Read more customer reviews

About Us

Our mission is to make the process of selling your firearm as easy and convenient as possible.

Selling a firearm can be time-consuming and legally complex. At webuyguns.com, we streamline the process by purchasing directly from you, saving you time and ensuring a legally compliant, hassle-free transaction. With decades of experience, we provide fair market evaluations and encourage you to compare our offers locally to see the value we bring.

Get Started