Valuation Guides by Make / Model Colt 1851 Navy
Published: May 26, 2025 | Updated: April 7, 2026
This range reflects current U.S. secondary market pricing and specific configurations, condition, or included accessories can move value above or below the range.
Colt Quality
The Colt 1851 Navy was a .36 caliber cap-and-ball revolver famed for its balance and reliability. Favored by many frontiersmen, it played a significant role in the mid-19th century.
If you are researching the value of a Colt 1851 Navy, current market prices depend on condition, configuration and production variant. You can also explore our full Colt firearm value guide to compare prices across other Colt models.
Its naval scene cylinder engraving and streamlined profile stand out among Colt’s black powder line. Collectors value authentic period examples for their historical significance.
At WeBuyGuns.com, we understand the market value of these firearms and are committed to providing you with a fair and competitive offer. Submit your Colt 1851 Navy today for a free valuation and let us make an offer that reflects the quality and legacy of your firearm.
The Colt 1851 Navy is available in a variety of models and configurations, each catering to different shooting needs and preferences. Below are some of the most popular variants, each offering unique features:
Colt 1851 Navy 2nd Model
Early production run featuring a small trigger guard and square-back design.
Colt 1851 Navy London
Manufactured at the London Armory with British proof marks, prized by collectors.
Don’t see your specific model listed? No problem!
We value firearms of all types, whether they’re common or unique.
Start your free, no-obligation offer!When determining the value of your Colt 1851 Navy, several factors come into play. Here’s what we consider:
Condition:
Firearms in excellent condition with clean bore, minimal wear, and no significant damage will command higher prices.
Accessories:
Adding accessories, optics, additional magazines and having original packaging can increase value.
Rarity:
Limited edition and vintage Colt models in pristine condition often have added value.
Market Demand:
Popular models perform well on the market due to their practicality and widespread use.
Original Box & Documentation:
Presence of the original Colt box or case can increase offer value, lack of the original box will typically decrease the offer value.
Aftermarket Modifications:
Aftermarket modifications and finishing can affect offer values but rarely add significant value in the secondary market.
About Us
We are the highest rated national gun buyer. We Buy Guns has purchased over 10,000 firearms from users in all 50 states, paying out over $5.1 million to sellers on our platform.
Values can vary based on condition, configuration, and current demand. Submit a few details and we’ll provide a clear, no-obligation offer based on today’s market.
Can’t find the answer you’re looking for? Reach out to our customer support team.
Understand the process of selling a firearm in your state with our in-depth guides. We break down local, state and federal regulations while providing the resources you need for a smooth, legal transaction.
Curious about your firearm’s value or what current market pricing is? Our manufacturer specific valuation guides provide insights into pricing, demand and key factors that affect value—helping you sell with confidence.
