What is a used Benelli Legacy worth today?

Based on current market trends, a Benelli Legacy in very good to excellent condition typically sells in the $1,200 to $1,600 range. Pricing can be lower for heavy wear or missing parts and higher for like-new condition, upgrades, or desirable configurations.

What factors affect the value of my Legacy?

Condition is the biggest driver, then configuration and included accessories. Things like overall wear, bore condition, finish, function, optics, extra magazines, chokes, boxes, paperwork, and original parts can all move the value up or down.

Will you buy my Legacy if it’s worn, modified, or missing parts?

Often yes. Normal wear, many common upgrades, and minor issues are usually fine. Just note anything important in the description and include clear photos so we can price it accurately.

How do I ship my firearm safely and legally?

After you accept an offer, we send a prepaid shipping label and step-by-step instructions. You’re responsible for packaging the firearm securely, then you drop it off with the carrier. All transfers are handled through the proper FFL process.

How quickly will I get paid?

Payment is sent by check or ACH direct deposit. After we receive and verify the firearm matches the submission, payment is issued quickly. You’ll choose your preferred method during acceptance.

Valuation Guides by Make / Model Benelli Legacy

Published: July 29, 2025 | Updated: April 7, 2026

Benelli Legacy Value & Current Market Price (2026)

Current Benelli Legacy market value: $1200 – $1600

This range reflects current U.S. secondary market pricing and specific configurations, condition, or included accessories can move value above or below the range.

Get a free offer on your firearm Our reviews ↓ Our process ↓

Benelli Quality

Valuing the Benelli Legacy

The Benelli Legacy is an elegant semi-automatic shotgun featuring high-polish bluing, detailed engraving, and high-grade walnut.

If you are researching the value of a Benelli Legacy, current market prices depend on condition, configuration and production variant. You can also explore our full Benelli firearm value guide to compare prices across other Benelli models.

It offers reliable inertia-driven cycling in a lightweight, refined package ideal for bird hunters who appreciate fine craftsmanship.

At WeBuyGuns.com, we understand the market value of these firearms and are committed to providing you with a fair and competitive offer. Submit your Benelli Legacy today for a free valuation and let us make an offer that reflects the quality and legacy of your firearm.

Common Variants of the Benelli Legacy

The Benelli Legacy is available in a variety of models and configurations, each catering to different shooting needs and preferences. Below are some of the most popular variants, each offering unique features:

Legacy 12 Gauge

Elegant semi-auto with gloss walnut stock, engraved receiver, and inertia action in 12 gauge.

Legacy 20 Gauge

Smaller gauge version with identical visual detailing and superb balance for upland hunting.

Don’t see your specific model listed? No problem!

We value firearms of all types, whether they’re common or unique.

Start your free, no-obligation offer!

Factors That Influence Benelli Legacy Values

When determining the value of your Benelli Legacy, several factors come into play. Here’s what we consider:

Condition: Firearms in excellent condition with clean bore, minimal wear, and no significant damage will command higher prices.
Accessories: Adding accessories, optics, additional magazines and having original packaging can increase value.
Rarity: Limited edition and vintage Benelli models in pristine condition often have added value.
Market Demand: Popular models perform well on the market due to their practicality and widespread use.
Original Box & Documentation: Presence of the original Benelli box or case can increase offer value, lack of the original box will typically decrease the offer value.
Aftermarket Modifications: Aftermarket modifications and finishing can affect offer values but rarely add significant value in the secondary market.

Recent customer reviews

michael daley

★★★★★ May 16, 2026

I got the best offer for my firearm and both weapon and payment transfer was flawless. I would 100% recommend using We Buy Guns.. I will definitely be back if i decide to sell another firearm..

Dan Kathy Davis

★★★★★ May 16, 2026

I was very impressed with every aspect of the interaction I had selling my firearm to We Buy Guns! They offered an amazingly fair price, led me through each next step to take in the process with ease, and communicated with me through each stage. I highly recommend using We By Guns!

Bernard Rotundo

★★★★★ May 15, 2026

The entire process of submitting info, acceptance of quote, and shipping, was easy to follow, straightforward and quick.

Paul Wallin

★★★★★ May 14, 2026

The is great place if you have some firearms you need or want to sale. They are legitimate and you get paid in a timely manner. It’s a quick and easy process.

kaelan mcclain

★★★★★ May 14, 2026

quick and simple liquidation of my firearm and easier than a pawn shop

Al Mosher

★★★★★ May 14, 2026

Better prices offered that the competition

Jonathan Gonzalez

★★★★★ May 14, 2026

WeBuyGuns is a great company! I had an excellent experience selling my handgun. Every other shop and website I tried failed to give me a fair deal, but WeBuyGuns offered a price that was very reasonable. Their process is straightforward and easy; I can honestly say you won’t be disappointed. I will definitely do business with them again in the future!

J Faz

★★★★★ May 12, 2026

What an easy and great transaction! I'm so glad I found this site. Much easier than trying to sell on Gunbroker and similar sites and the price paid was VERY fair!

McChicken Sandwiches

★★★★★ May 11, 2026

These folks are great, responsive to questions on their website, and make a very easy streamlined process.

Jonathan Latimer

★★★★★ May 10, 2026

I really appreciate that this business makes the process so easy. They also offer fair prices for what you have. I have never been lowballed and it’s the reason I continue to work with them.

Start your free offer Read more customer reviews

About Us

Our mission is to make the process of selling your firearm as easy and convenient as possible.

We are the highest rated national gun buyer. We Buy Guns has purchased over 11,000 firearms from users in all 50 states, paying out over $5.45 million to sellers on our platform.

Most sellers are paid within 24 hours after inspection and verification.: Fast payment
We provide clear communications from shipment to inspection and payment.: Clear timeline
All payments are issued securely through verified payment methods.: Secure processing
Payment progress and updates are available in your user portal.: Status updates
No hidden fees or surprises — the amount you accept is what you receive.: Transparent offers
Our team is available to answer questions and help at any point.: Dedicated support

Frequently asked questions

Can’t find the answer you’re looking for? Reach out to our customer support team.

What is a used Benelli Legacy worth today?: Based on current market trends, a Benelli Legacy in very good to excellent condition typically sells in the $1,200 to $1,600 range. Pricing can be lower for heavy wear or missing parts and higher for like-new condition, upgrades, or desirable configurations.
What factors affect the value of my Legacy?: Condition is the biggest driver, then configuration and included accessories. Things like overall wear, bore condition, finish, function, optics, extra magazines, chokes, boxes, paperwork, and original parts can all move the value up or down.
Will you buy my Legacy if it’s worn, modified, or missing parts?: Often yes. Normal wear, many common upgrades, and minor issues are usually fine. Just note anything important in the description and include clear photos so we can price it accurately.
How do I ship my firearm safely and legally?: After you accept an offer, we send a prepaid shipping label and step-by-step instructions. You’re responsible for packaging the firearm securely, then you drop it off with the carrier. All transfers are handled through the proper FFL process.
How quickly will I get paid?: Payment is sent by check or ACH direct deposit. After we receive and verify the firearm matches the submission, payment is issued quickly. You’ll choose your preferred method during acceptance.