Is selling my firearm to WeBuyGuns.com legal in New York?

Yes. We are a federally licensed firearms dealer located in the state of Indiana. You, the seller, are covered under our license just as you would be if you walked into our store. There are no laws preventing you from selling your firearm to us.

Can I sell a firearm I do not have the original box or paperwork?

Yes. In most cases we only need clear photos and accurate details so we can make a documented offer. If anything else is needed, we will tell you during the review.

Does WeBuyGuns.com purchase multiple firearms, collections or estates?

Absolutely! Once firearm information has been submitted, you will have the ability to submit additional firearms for review and offers. These firearms will be viewable from your user panel, which you access from your initial offer email. If you have a large number of firearms or an estate, it is best to contact us directly (to save you time).

We will either send you a check, or we will issue the funds via a secure ACH direct deposit. During the offer approval process, you will tell us which method of payment you prefer.

What if I inherited firearms and don’t know much about them?

Inherited firearms are common. You can start by sending photos or a simple list of items and we’ll help identify what you have, explain what affects value and guide you through the next steps before anything is shipped.

In New York, do private firearm sales have to go through a dealer and background check?

In most cases, yes. New York generally requires private transfers to be processed through a licensed dealer so a background check can be performed. Selling directly to a licensed dealer like WeBuyGuns.com is a straightforward way to stay compliant because the transfer and records are handled through the FFL process.

Do I need a Semi-Automatic Rifle License to sell a semi-auto rifle in New York?

A Semi-Automatic Rifle License is required to purchase or take ownership of a semiautomatic rifle in New York (for acquisitions on or after September 4, 2022) but selling to an FFL is still the cleanest compliant path regardless of licensing questions. If anything about the configuration or eligibility needs to be confirmed, we will tell you before anything ships.

I inherited a handgun in New York. Can I sell it without getting stuck in a long local permit process?

Handguns in New York are heavily regulated and many counties treat inheritance transfers as paperwork-heavy. Selling directly to a licensed dealer is often the simplest way to create a documented, compliant transfer and avoid the uncertainty of trying to navigate a person-to-person path. Send photos and details and we will guide you on the cleanest route before shipping.

Sell Guns New York

Published: June 25, 2024 | Updated: March 6, 2026

Sell Your Gun in New York - Fast, Legal & Hassle-Free

We purchase firearms statewide from New York City to Buffalo — through a fully licensed, online process designed to make selling your firearm simple, documented and compliant with New York’s strict transfer rules.

Trusted by 40,000+ sellers · 900+ Google reviews · Over $4.7M paid out to users

Submit your firearm for a free cash offer

Looking to understand New York's private transfer laws before selling? Read our New York legal guide →

We have purchased 189 firearms from sellers across New York through our streamlined, fully licensed online process.

New York is not a “parking lot meetup” state. Most transfers must be processed through a licensed dealer with a background check, and requirements can vary by county and city. We provide a documented offer based on current market demand then handle the dealer-to-dealer transfer, shipping instructions and clear chain of custody end to end so you can sell without guessing at paperwork or local process.

We provide Free offers Fast Payment Fully licensed process Free insured shipping Bill of sale U.S.-based customer support

Recent examples of firearms we purchased from New York sellers

Handgun

Glock

.380 • Excellent Condition

Purchased for $250

Completed Mar 2026

Handgun

Canik

SFX Rival

9mm • Excellent Condition

Purchased for $400

Completed Mar 2026

Handgun

Smith And Wesson

Shield Plus

9mm • Excellent Condition

Purchased for $300

Completed Mar 2026

Rifle

Armi Jager

AP=74

22lr • Good Condition

Purchased for $150

Completed Feb 2026

Handgun

Springfield

XDM Elite Compact

9mm • Very Good Condition

Purchased for $400

Completed Feb 2026

Handgun

S&W

6906

9mm • Very Good Condition

Purchased for $300

Completed Feb 2026

Rifle

Armi-Jager

AP-74

22LR • Good Condition

Purchased for $150

Completed Feb 2026

Rifle

Zastava

Yugo 59/66

7.62x39 • Very Good Condition

Purchased for $400

Completed Feb 2026

Reviews from New York Sellers

darrin scali

★★★★★ Dec 8, 2025

Very fair and very knowledgeable

Joe Desimone

★★★★★ Nov 5, 2025

Super smooth aggravation free transaction

Robert Schwarzler

★★★★★ Nov 7, 2025

Fast honest transaction. Got payed for my guns within a week. Fair prices.

Warner Perry

★★★★★ Jul 23, 2025

Very expedient and professional!

jeff toscano

★★★★★ Jun 9, 2025

Super easy and competitive offer.

Steve Faes

★★★★★ Feb 12, 2025

No hassle way to sell your used gun. Follow the well written instructions they provide and all will end well. It did for me.

Get a free, no-obligation offer on your firearm

Major New York metros we serve

If you can ship a package from New York, you can sell directly to us.

We specialize in assessing and buying high-value collections and estates from New York residents, including WWII Collectibles, Machine Guns and Pre-Ban Firearms.

Compare your options

Ways to sell a gun in New York

Most sellers in New York compare local shops, pawn shops, auctions and private sales. The tradeoffs usually come down to price, time and legal responsibility. Below is a quick breakdown, plus a side-by-side comparison.

Local gun shops

Convenient if you want to drop it off in person, but offers can vary widely and many shops price for resale margin.

• Fast in-person option
• Offers depend on current inventory
• You may need to visit many shops

Detailed comparison: We Buy Guns vs Gun Shops

Pawn shops

Usually the quickest route, but commonly the lowest payout since the goal is short-term resale or loans, not market matching.

• Very fast
• Lowest typical offers
• Limited firearm expertise

Detailed comparison: We Buy Guns vs Pawn Shops

Auction Companies

Auctions can work well for rare or collectible firearms, but the final price depends on bidding activity and timing.

• Weeks to months to complete sale
• Commissions reduce final payout
• No guaranteed sale price

Detailed comparison: We Buy Guns vs Auctions

Consignment

Consignment allows a dealer to list and market the firearm on your behalf, but the timeline depends on when a buyer appears and local demand.

• Firearm remains unsold until a buyer is found
• Commissions reduce final payout
• Timing and final price are uncertain

Detailed comparison: We Buy Guns vs Consignment

Private sale

Private sales can avoid dealer fees, but require firearms knowledge, managing listings, coordinating meetups and handling compliance yourself.

• Must meet buyers in person
• Highest legal compliance risk
• Time spent listing and negotiating

Detailed comparison: We Buy Guns vs Private Sale

WeBuyGuns.com

Licensed online buyer

Sell your gun online and from home to a federally licensed buyer. Shipping and transfer are handled in compliance with applicable firearms laws.

• No listings or stranger meetups
• Free shipping & clear instructions
• Licensed, compliant process
• Fast payment

How We Buy Guns compares to other ways to sell

Option	Typical offer	Time to payment	Convenience	Legal risk
Local gun shop In-person sale	Often lower (local resale only)	Same day (varies)	In-person & expect negotiation	Low
Pawn shop Fast cash	Low	Same day	In-person visit required	Low
Auctions / consignment Higher upside, more wait	Variable (fees apply)	Weeks to months	Drop-off, paperwork, waiting	Moderate
Private sale / classifieds You handle everything	Variable	Unpredictable	Meetups, negotiation, messaging	High
WeBuyGuns.com Licensed online buyer	Often much higher We make offers based on the national market	Issued same day when we receive the firearm	No travelNo hassle, no haggling	Very low We handle compliance

Our process for firearm sellers in New York

Our process is designed to help New York sellers complete a legally compliant, documented sale with clear steps fast offer turnaround and fast payment.

Tell us what you have: Use our offer submission form. Share the make, model and condition, along with photos of the firearm, optics, accessories and any markings that affect value.
Get a fast and free offer: We review the details and provide a written offer based on the firearm, configuration and current demand, usually within 24 hours.
Ship with clear instructions: If you accept our offer, we provide a prepaid shipping label and clear, step-by-step instructions so your firearm is packaged and shipped correctly.
Get paid quickly: Once received and inspected, we issue payment using the method selected during checkout and finalize the documented transfer.

Compliance note: All firearms are transferred and processed through our Federal Firearms License (FFL). If your item has special considerations (NFA items, inherited firearms, unusual configurations), we’ll walk you through what applies and what to expect before you ship anything.

Have questions about the process, how to get started, or your specific firearms?

Call us at (317) 804-8713

Our track record

We are trusted by firearm sellers nationwide

Sell with confidence — no hassle and no hidden fees. Our streamlined process has facilitated thousands of firearms transactions nationwide, paying out over $4.7 million to users on our platform.

Sellers on the platform: 40,000+
Paid out to sellers: $4.7 Million

We purchase firearms and ensure compliance in every state, including New York: Fast nationwide service
All transactions are handled by firearms professionals to ensure legal compliance: Licensed FFL with a class 3 SOT

What our most recent customers have to say

jeff moore

★★★★★ Mar 14, 2026

I sold them 3 Handguns that I no longer used, and the sale went Flawless and I checked other Online Gun buyers and the best price was right here at We Buy Guns, fair and fast payment

Armando

★★★★★ Mar 14, 2026

Awesome service from WeBuyGuns. They gave me prompt attention, answered all of my questions, and I received a great deal. I recommend doing business with WBG. I am. AV from Miami.

Joseph Abdullah

★★★★★ Mar 14, 2026

This reviewer left a star rating only.

Start your free offer Read more customer reviews

Frequently asked questions

If you can’t find the answer you’re looking for, reach out to customer support or View all FAQs

Is selling my firearm to WeBuyGuns.com legal in New York?: Yes. We are a federally licensed firearms dealer located in the state of Indiana. You, the seller, are covered under our license just as you would be if you walked into our store. There are no laws preventing you from selling your firearm to us.
Can I sell a firearm I do not have the original box or paperwork?: Yes. In most cases we only need clear photos and accurate details so we can make a documented offer. If anything else is needed, we will tell you during the review.
How long are offers good for?: Offers are valid for 14 days.
Does WeBuyGuns.com purchase multiple firearms, collections or estates?: Absolutely! Once firearm information has been submitted, you will have the ability to submit additional firearms for review and offers. These firearms will be viewable from your user panel, which you access from your initial offer email. If you have a large number of firearms or an estate, it is best to contact us directly (to save you time).
How do I get paid?: We will either send you a check, or we will issue the funds via a secure ACH direct deposit. During the offer approval process, you will tell us which method of payment you prefer.
What if I inherited firearms and don’t know much about them?: Inherited firearms are common. You can start by sending photos or a simple list of items and we’ll help identify what you have, explain what affects value and guide you through the next steps before anything is shipped.
In New York, do private firearm sales have to go through a dealer and background check?: In most cases, yes. New York generally requires private transfers to be processed through a licensed dealer so a background check can be performed. Selling directly to a licensed dealer like WeBuyGuns.com is a straightforward way to stay compliant because the transfer and records are handled through the FFL process.
Do I need a Semi-Automatic Rifle License to sell a semi-auto rifle in New York?: A Semi-Automatic Rifle License is required to purchase or take ownership of a semiautomatic rifle in New York (for acquisitions on or after September 4, 2022) but selling to an FFL is still the cleanest compliant path regardless of licensing questions. If anything about the configuration or eligibility needs to be confirmed, we will tell you before anything ships.
I inherited a handgun in New York. Can I sell it without getting stuck in a long local permit process?: Handguns in New York are heavily regulated and many counties treat inheritance transfers as paperwork-heavy. Selling directly to a licensed dealer is often the simplest way to create a documented, compliant transfer and avoid the uncertainty of trying to navigate a person-to-person path. Send photos and details and we will guide you on the cleanest route before shipping.

Start your free offer

Licensed process • Shipping guidance • Fast payment