Holiday Hours : We will be closed December 24th, 25th and 26th in observance of Christmas Eve, Christmas Day, and Internal Inventory (the 26th). Any packages scheduled for delivery on those days will be delivered Tuesday the 30th.

Pre-Ban Valuation Guide Colt AR-15 A2 Sporter II

Published: December 18, 2025 | Updated: December 20, 2025

How Much is My Colt AR-15 A2 Sporter II Worth?

The Colt AR-15 A2 Sporter II is one of Colt’s best-known civilian A2-era rifles. Buyers value Sporter II rifles for Colt markings, period-correct A2 configuration, and documented pre-ban manufacture. Originality and condition have an outsized impact on pricing, especially in states where verified pre-ban rifles can command a premium.

Pre-ban pricing is driven by documented production era and how closely the rifle remains period-correct. Small details like markings, original parts, and finish can materially change value.

Get Started About Us ↓ Our Reviews ↓

Want to compare more models? Browse the full pre-ban valuation guide.

About the Colt AR-15 A2 Sporter II

The Colt AR-15 A2 Sporter II reflects Colt’s A2-era commercial production and sits squarely in the collector and restricted-state demand overlap that drives much of the pre-ban market. Sporter II rifles are often purchased as “keep it original” Colts, meaning configuration and finish matter as much as function. The strongest premiums typically go to rifles that remain close to factory setup with consistent finish, correct receiver markings, and correct major components. Rifles that were modernized over time with rails, barrel swaps, optics mounts, or refinishing often trade more like shooters than collectible pre-ban examples.

Colt AR-15 A2 Sporter II Pre-Ban Values & Variants

Pre-ban Colt AR-15 A2 Sporter II rifles are valued for their documented era and how closely they remain period-correct. Most examples range from $600 to $1,500, depending on originality, condition, and demand in restricted states.

Pre-ban note: For the Colt AR-15 A2 Sporter II, pre-ban generally means it was manufactured before September 13, 1994. Although the federal ban expired, some states still treat documented pre-ban rifles differently which can increase demand.

How to confirm your Colt AR-15 A2 Sporter II is pre-ban

  • Receiver markings and model designation
  • Overall configuration and major components (barrel, sights, furniture, muzzle device)
  • Signs of permanent modification (drilled receivers, refinished metal, non-factory machining)
  • Consistency of finish and matching-era parts
  • Box, manuals, receipts, or original parts (if included)

Tip: photos of receiver markings, overall configuration, and any documentation help us move faster and price more accurately.

Common Variants & Value Ranges

Pre-ban Colt AR-15 A2 Sporter II values vary based on originality and configuration. The ranges below reflect how collectors typically group these rifles in today’s market.

  • Modified / Non-Original Configuration

    Original upper with foreign lower or altered configuration

    Estimated Value: $600 – $1,000

  • Standard Configuration

    Mostly original Sporter II rifle

    Estimated Value: $800 – $1,500

  • Collector-Grade (Carbine Variant)

    Documented pre-ban carbine configuration

    Estimated Value: $900 – $1,200

Collector notes: Sporter II pricing is heavily photo-driven. Clear receiver marking photos and full-configuration shots help confirm period-correct setup. If you have the original box, manuals, receipts, or original parts that were replaced over time, include them because they can increase buyer confidence and value.

Factors That Influence Colt AR-15 A2 Sporter II Values

Original Configuration:

Rifles that remain in original, period-correct configuration typically bring the highest offers. Correct furniture, correct barrel profile, and correct small parts can materially affect collector demand.

Receiver Markings & Documentable Era:

Markings help confirm model and manufacturing era. Clear photos of receiver markings and overall configuration help verify pre-ban status and support stronger offers.

Correct Major Components:

Barrel type, sights, upper receiver details, stock and handguards can influence value when they remain period-correct. Major component swaps often matter more than small, reversible changes.

Condition & Finish:

Original finish and honest wear generally outperform refinished examples. Rust, pitting, heavy scratches, and mismatched parts can reduce value even if the rifle functions well.

Modifications & Permanence:

Aftermarket rails, barrel swaps, refinishing, or drilled receivers often reduce collector value. Permanent modifications typically matter more than reversible changes like furniture swaps.

State-Driven Demand:

In states with ongoing feature restrictions, documented pre-ban Colt rifles may sell faster and command a premium compared to similar post-ban rifles.

Compare your options

How selling a pre-ban firearms through WeBuyGuns compares to your other options

store Local gun shop

Usually fast, but most shops have limited cash on hand and may not specialize in older, rare or high-value pieces.

Offers often favor a quick resale, not the long-term collector value.

Auctions Auctions and consignment

Potential upside, but you wait for the sale, pay commissions and still carry uncertainty around final prices and timelines.

private sale Private sales or classifieds

Can take months, involve strangers and require you to manage listings, messages and transfers one gun at a time. For estates, that can add stress to an already heavy situation.

Selling to WeBuyGuns.com Selling to WeBuyGuns

You get a single, expert valuation and offer for the entire collection, prepaid shipping labels and clear expectations up front. No fees, no pressure and no need to piece out guns one by one.

Our track record

We are trusted by firearm sellers nationwide

Sell your pre-ban firearms with confidence — no hassle and no hidden fees. Our streamlined process has facilitated thousands of firearms transactions nationwide, paying out over $4.1 million to users on our platform.

Sellers on the platform
36,500+
Paid out to sellers
$4.1 Million
We purchase firearms and ensure compliance in every state
Fast nationwide service
All transactions are handled by firearms professionals to ensure legal compliance
Licensed FFL with a class 3 SOT

Secure, compliant and trackable from start to finish

box-3d-67
Safe, secure shipping handled for you
Firearms ship directly to our licensed FFL — never a private residence. We cover the shipping cost and provide clear packing instructions to ensure everything arrives safely.
virtual-assistant-2
White-glove logistics from start to finish
We generate your prepaid shipping labels and guide you through each step, including packing, labeling and drop-off, so the entire process stays simple and stress-free.
touch-id
Compliance handled on your behalf
We maintain all required federal records and guide you through the legal steps, so once your firearms arrive, responsibility transfers fully to our licensed facility.

We’re happy to talk through the process step by step so you understand exactly what will happen and when.

Call us at (317) 804-8713 if you have any questions.

Chris Wing - Owner WeBuyGuns

With pre-ban firearms, value is defined by documented production era, configuration, and originality. Small details materially affect pricing, and accurate valuation requires familiarity with how collectors buy these rifles today.

Our team evaluates every pre-ban firearm individually. We do not rely on automated pricing or assumptions. Each offer is grounded in real details and current market demand, reflecting how these firearms are actually valued when money changes hands.

Chris Wing
Owner, WeBuyGuns

Ready to get an offer on your pre-ban Colt AR-15 A2 Sporter II?

Submit your firearm to get a free offer with professional support every step of the way.

16 launch Submit your firearm for a free offer Learn more about our proces
topo map

Recent customer reviews

16 launch Start your free offer Read more customer reviews

Frequently asked questions

If you can’t find the answer you’re looking for, reach out to customer support or View all FAQs

Is this legal?
Yes. We are a federally licensed firearms dealer located in the state of Indiana. You, the seller, are covered under our license just as you would be if you walked into our store with the item. There are no laws preventing you from selling your firearm to us.
What makes a Colt AR-15 A2 Sporter II more valuable?
Originality and correct Colt markings are the biggest drivers of value. Rifles that remain close to factory configuration with consistent finish and correct major components generally command stronger offers. Collector-grade condition and included documentation can increase value.
What does “pre-ban” mean for the Colt AR-15 A2 Sporter II?
Pre-ban generally means the rifle was manufactured before September 13, 1994. While the federal ban expired, some states still treat documented pre-ban rifles differently which can increase demand and value for verified examples.
Do modifications reduce the value of a Sporter II?
Often, yes. Many buyers want a Colt-marked pre-ban rifle that remains period-correct. Modern rails, optics mounts, barrel swaps, or refinishing can reduce collector demand. If you kept the original parts, including them with the rifle can help preserve value.
What photos should I include for an accurate Sporter II valuation?
Start with receiver markings and overall configuration photos. Include clear left and right receiver markings, close-ups of the upper and barrel area if markings are present, and full photos showing stock, handguards, sights, and muzzle device. Also include photos of any box, manuals, or accessories.
How do I sell a Colt AR-15 A2 Sporter II to WeBuyGuns.com?
Submit your rifle using our online offer form and include clear photos of markings and condition. If you have a box, manuals, receipts, or original parts, include photos of those too. We’ll review and send a competitive offer. If accepted, we provide shipping instructions and a prepaid label and you’ll be responsible for packaging the firearm securely.
How long are offers good for?
Offers are valid for 14 days.
Can I sell multiple firearms?
Absolutely! Once firearm information has been submitted, you will have the ability to submit additional firearms for review and offers. These firearms will be viewable from your user panel, which you access from your initial offer email. If you have a large number of firearms or an estate, view our guide on gun collections.
View all FAQs